top of page

Tiktok, Instagram Reels or YouTube Shorts, Which is best for you?


In this article, we delve into the world of short-form video content and compare the three major players: YouTube Shorts, Instagram Reels, and TikTok. Short-form videos have taken the internet by storm, captivating audiences with their engaging and snappy nature. As a digital marketer or content creator, understanding the unique features and advantages of each platform can help you strategize and maximize your reach to a wider audience. Let's dive into the details of each platform and discover which one can best suit your goals.

Tiktok, Instagram Reels or YouTube Shorts,

YouTube Shorts

YouTube Shorts is YouTube's answer to the growing popularity of short-form videos. It allows creators to upload vertical videos that are up to 60 seconds in length, perfect for delivering quick and impactful content to viewers. The platform's vast user base and seamless integration with the YouTube app make it an appealing choice for those already familiar with the YouTube ecosystem.

Key Features of YouTube Shorts

  • Music Library: YouTube Shorts boasts an extensive music library, offering a wide array of soundtracks that can add flair and creativity to your videos.

  • Creation Tools: The platform provides an assortment of creative tools, including speed controls, timer, and filters, enabling users to craft captivating and visually appealing content.

  • Community Interaction: Like other platforms, YouTube Shorts encourages community interaction through likes, comments, and shares, fostering engagement and potential virality.

Instagram Reels

Instagram Reels, a feature of Instagram, is another dominant force in the short-form video space. With a maximum duration of 60 seconds, Reels offers users the opportunity to showcase their creativity in a fun and visually appealing manner. Given Instagram's immense user base and seamless integration with other Instagram features, Reels can be a powerful tool for brand promotion and content dissemination.

Key Features of Instagram Reels

  • Editing Tools: Instagram Reels provides users with a variety of editing tools, such as AR effects, text overlay, and video speed controls, facilitating the creation of captivating and polished content.

  • Discoverability: Reels can be discovered not only through a user's profile but also on the "Explore" page, increasing the likelihood of reaching a broader audience.

  • Hashtag Challenges: Instagram frequently introduces hashtag challenges, encouraging users to participate and engage with trending content, which can lead to higher visibility.


TikTok has taken the world by storm, captivating users with its addictive and endlessly entertaining short-form videos. With a 60-second time limit, TikTok empowers users to create engaging and shareable content, often leading to viral trends and challenges.

Key Features of TikTok

  • For You Page (FYP): TikTok's "For You Page" is a highly personalized feed that showcases content based on users' interests, ensuring higher visibility for relevant videos.

  • Duet and Stitch: The Duet feature allows users to collaborate and respond to videos, fostering a strong sense of community and interaction. Stitch, on the other hand, allows users to incorporate parts of other videos into their own, promoting content cross-pollination.

  • Effects and Filters: TikTok offers an extensive library of special effects and filters that add an element of creativity to videos, encouraging users to experiment with their content.

Video Length

Initially, the video length was the same for each of the short-form content. However, now it’s different for each of them. (video length may have changed again by the time you read this)

Tiktok, Instagram Reels or YouTube Shorts,

Shopping Links

Tiktok, Instagram Reels or YouTube Shorts,

Most active users

Tiktok, Instagram Reels or YouTube Shorts,

Which platform is more user-friendly?

  • TikTok is a very reliable and easy-to-use app. Here, you can easily edit your videos or posts and add whatever you want. You can easily add filters or add visual effects easily and free of cost.

  • Instagram reels also offer these editing and free-to-use stuff, but it is limited to some extent. It is quite user-friendly but not like TikTok.

  • YouTube shorts offer a minimum amount of editing stuff, where you can trim or edit your short videos. It is not very user-friendly.

Some important stats

According to a recent study by socialinsider:

  • TikTok is the short-form video platform with the highest engagement rate

  • TikTok registers 2x more comments than Reels and Shorts

  • The number of TikToks posted is doubled compared to Instagram Reels & Shorts

  • Instagram Reels score the highest watch rate

Pro tips for creating a top-notch short-form video content strategy

For any business that wants to succeed in the fierce competition of social media marketing, staying on top of the trends is crucial.

And when it comes to social trends, the one with the biggest impact on brands’ social media strategies is the growth of short-form video consumption.

Obviously, when deciding to leverage video content, social media managers must first choose the social platform that will help them achieve their brand objectives.

  • If you're interested in getting a higher watch rate on your videos you should create more content tailored for Instagram Reels.

  • If your goal is to get higher engagement, you should go for TikTok instead, as TikTok is the best-performing platform.

Furthermore, as a marketing manager, if you’re thinking about creating a content calendar for various short-form video platforms (or even only one), it's very important to keep to your industry’s average posting frequency.

That’s to make sure, you’re not falling behind on your competitors and the platform’s algorithms.

As a starting point, here are our recommendations based on the data:

  • TikTok: post about 15 videos per month

  • Reels: post about 10 videos per month

  • Shorts: post about 8 videos per month.

Now you have these starting points for integrating short-form video content into your social media strategy, just unleash your creativity!

Summing Up

YouTube Shorts, Instagram Reels, and TikTok are all platforms that allow users to create and share short-form video content.

Each platform has its own strengths and weaknesses, and the best choice for a creator or brand will depend on its specific goals and target audience.

YouTube Shorts is a solid choice for creators and brands looking to reach a wide and diverse audience, as well as those who want to monetize their content through advertising and sponsorship.

Instagram Reels is a good choice for creators and brands looking to promote visually appealing content and build a strong following, while TikTok is a good choice for those who want to showcase their creative skills and be a part of a highly engaged and active community.

Ultimately, the choice between these three platforms will depend on the specific needs and goals of the creator or brand, as well as the preferences of their target audience.

Call us NOW on 0428 881 703 for an obligation free chat to see how we can help you boost sale and revenue with Tiktok, Instagram Reels or YouTube Shorts,

Tiktok, Instagram Reels or YouTube Shorts,


Commenting has been turned off.
bottom of page